Archiv článků: leden 2013

21. 01.

Gas, radiation and rockets

Adrian Wheeler Přečteno 5339 krát

Not much frightened the Wehrmacht, but the Australians did. When ANZAC troops captured Tobruk at the point of a bayonet, blood ran in the streets. Caesar would not have been impressed: unlike his own proto-Nazis, the Ozzies left women, children and animals alone.

Later that evening groups of Australians were found celebrating arm-in-arm with their captives, swapping hats and sharing bottles liberated from Italian cellars.

The morals of warfare have never been much of a discussion topic among the soldiers I have known. For those who considered themselves religious,the Old Testament was ambiguous: you were not allowed to look at a comrade’s wife but exterminating the inhabitants of a village earned divine approval. Most professional troops leave the higher questions to the higher-ups. For Hitler’s myrmidons – brave, efficient and brutal – this was, conveniently, also a legal obligation.

What intrigues me is the attitude of thoughtful people in uniform. With few exceptions, poets regard war as intrinsically bad. With few exceptions, prose-writers accept it as natural. In the late twentieth century readers could choose between two polar extremes: John Keegan or Greenham Common. Serious analysts like Philip Matyszak leave the subject alone, using various techniques – in his case, wit – to isolate the question: how can good men kill?

When I was thirty I had a hero. He was the head of a large electronics company and my job was to write his speeches. He had many virtues: a champion swimmer, he was also an expert calligrapher and could have been a four-star chef; he looked like Harrison Ford and had several patents on military electronic devices. He was also an ardent Roman Catholic.

I was once giving him a lift home and asked how a religious person could spend his life inventing weapons. He was silent for a minute and I imagined he was struggling with this moral quandary. Then I looked across at him and realised he simply didn’t understand the question.

Science seems as ready to produce cluster-bombs as air-conditioning. Do scientists work in a moral vacuum?

The life of Fritz Haber was ambiguous to an extreme degree. He won the Nobel Prize in 1918 for inventing a chemical method of producing fertiliser. Half the world’s food production now depends on the Haber-Bosch process. But at the same time he played a pre-eminent role in the development of chemical warfare during World War One; he is often called the ‘father’ of poison gas. Besotted with the Kaiser’s militaristic society and anxious to be recognised as a true German, Haber devoted himself to inventing ever more deadly battlefield toxins, despite their prohibition by the Hague Convention of 1907.

It cost him his wife, who committed suicide, aghast, and his son, who also died by his own hand. Haber said: ‘In peace-time a scientist belongs to the world, but in wartime he belongs to his country’.

Robert Oppenheimer was also dubbed a ‘father’, this time of the atomic bomb. A brilliant, troubled and deeply enigmatic personality, Oppenheimer was a child prodigy who could master any subject and any language at the drop of a hat. As a physicist he was world-class but never focussed sufficiently to reach the heights of which he was capable. He made his mark on history when General Groves, the obnoxious but highly-effective manager of the Manhattan Project, picked Oppenheimer – to everyone’s amazement – as head of the Los Alamos research enterprise. This unlikely candidate turned out to possess extraordinary leadership skills, co-ordinating and driving a galaxy of scientific talent racing against time to create the bomb before the Germans.

When the Trinity test at Alamogordo proved successful, producing the world’s first atomic fireball, Oppenheimer quoted (from memory, and in the original language) the Bhagavad Gita: ‘I am become death, the destroyer of worlds’. Witnesses described his reaction as one of intense relief.
Later in life Oppenheimer did his best to encourage neutral, international supervision of atomic weapons and opposed the development of the hydrogen bomb. He was ostracized by the US atomic community when the Cold War gathered pace, losing his security clearance in dubious circumstances. He travelled the world lecturing on nuclear issues and the cause of peace. Presidents Kennedy and Johnson took steps to rehabilitate him with the award of the Enrico Fermi Medal in 1963; he died in 1967. Oppenheimer may personify the conflict between moral sensibility and scientific or patriotic urges - one which caused Haber no problems at all.

Wernher von Braun’s moral ambivalence has been immortalised by the musical mathematician Tom Lehrer. Dedicated from childhood to the embryonic science of rocketry, von Braun dreamed of space-flight and spent every waking hour experimenting with ways of defeating gravity. The problem was always lack of money. The solution came in the form of the Third Reich where, in spite of Hitler’s lukewarm support, the Wehrmacht and the SS competed to own the missile systems which von Braun was developing. He joined the party in 1937 and the SS in 1940.

Von Braun’s V2 caused such catastrophic damage to London (not to mention Antwerp, Liege and twelve other cities) that the British Government imposed a news blackout. There was simply no defence against this weapon, an ICBM years ahead of its time. Over 3,000 were launched.

The black shadow on von Braun’s reputation stems not from the use of rockets against civilians but from the methods used to manufacture them. Over 20,000 slave labourers died in the Mittelbau-Dora production caverns from beatings, starvation and exemplary hangings. Did von Braun know? He denied it, but both Guy Morand and Robert Cazabonne testified after the war that von Braun not only watched executions but also personally ordered floggings.

Von Braun, too, is known as a ‘father’ - in his case of the United States’ successful mission to land men on the moon. He was without question a brilliant scientist and a visionary. His adherence to the Nazi state was, he claimed, passive. The US authorities were happy to acquiesce. But there are doubts about von Braun’s veracity and similar misgivings about the allies’ willingness to overlook alleged war-crimes in the case of valuable ex-Nazis. Perhaps Mort Sahl’s sardonic comment stands as an epitaph: ‘I aim for the stars, but sometimes I hit London’.

Of the three, it is easiest to sympathise with Robert Oppenheimer. He seems to have possessed a conscience and to have spent the post-war years trying to minimise the consequences of his wartime endeavours. But, ironically, his achievements caused more death and destruction than the efforts of Haber and von Braun combined.

Do scientists live in a moral vacuum? In these three examples, not to mention my hero’s, they certainly appear to suspend their moral principles when governments tell them to. Maybe Haber was right, and in wartime a scientist does indeed ‘belong to his country’. How depressing, and how dangerous.






Blogeři abecedně

A Aktuálně.cz Blog · Atapana Mnislav Zelený B Baar Vladimír · Babka Michael · Balabán Miloš · Bartoníček Radek · Bartošek Jan · Bartošová Ela · Bavlšíková Adéla · Bečková Kateřina · Bednář Vojtěch · Bělobrádek Pavel · Beránek Jan · Berkovcová Jana · Bernard Josef · Berwid-Buquoy Jan · Bielinová Petra · Bína Jiří · Bízková Rut · Blaha Stanislav · Blažek Kamil · Bobek Miroslav · Boehmová Tereza · Brenna Yngvar · Bureš Radim · Bůžek Lukáš · Byčkov Semjon C Cerman Ivo · Cizinsky Ludvik Č Černoušek Štěpán · Česko Chytré · Čipera Erik · Čtenářův blog D David Jiří · Davis Magdalena · Dienstbier Jiří · Dlabajová Martina · Dolejš Jiří · Dostál Ondřej · Dudák Vladislav · Duka Dominik · Duong Nguyen Thi Thuy · Dvořák Jan · Dvořák Petr · Dvořáková Vladimíra E Elfmark František F Fafejtová Klára · Fajt Jiří · Fendrych Martin · Fiala Petr · Fibigerová Markéta · Fischer Pavel G Gálik Stanislav · Gargulák Karel · Geislerová Ester · Girsa Václav · Glanc Tomáš · Goláň Tomáš · Gregorová Markéta · Groman Martin H Hájek Jan · Hála Martin · Halík Tomáš · Hamáček Jan · Hampl Václav · Hamplová Jana · Hapala Jiří · Hasenkopf Pavel · Hastík František · Havel Petr · Heller Šimon · Herman Daniel · Heroldová Martina · Hilšer Marek · Hladík Petr · Hlaváček Petr · Hlubučková Andrea · Hnízdil Jan · Hokovský Radko · Holásková Kamila · Holmerová Iva · Honzák Radkin · Horáková Adéla · Horký Petr · Hořejš Nikola · Hořejší Václav · Hrabálek Alexandr · Hradilková Jana · Hrstka Filip · Hřib Zdeněk · Hubálková Pavla · Hubinger Václav · Hülle Tomáš · Hušek Radek · Hvížďala Karel CH Charanzová Dita · Chlup Radek · Chromý Heřman · Chýla Jiří · Chytil Ondřej J Janda Jakub · Janeček Karel · Janeček Vít · Janečková Tereza · Janyška Petr · Jelínková Michaela Mlíčková · Jourová Věra · Just Jiří · Just Vladimír K Kaláb Tomáš · Kania Ondřej · Karfík Filip · Karlický Josef · Klan Petr · Klepárník  Vít · Klíma Pavel · Klíma Vít · Klimeš David · Klusoň Jan · Kňapová Kateřina · Kocián Antonín · Kohoutová Růžena · Koch Paul Vincent · Kolaja Marcel · Kolářová Marie · Kolínská Petra · Kolovratník Martin · Konrádová Kateřina · Kopeček Lubomír · Kostlán František · Kotišová Miluš · Koudelka Zdeněk · Koutská Petra Schwarz · Kozák Kryštof · Krafl Martin · Krása Václav · Kraus Ivan · Kroupová Johana · Křeček Stanislav · Kubr Milan · Kučera Josef · Kučera Vladimír · Kučerová Karolína · Kuchař Jakub · Kuchař Jaroslav · Kukal Petr · Kupka Martin · Kuras Benjamin · Kutílek Petr · Kužílek Oldřich · Kyselý Ondřej L Laně Tomáš · Linhart Zbyněk · Lipavský Jan · Lipold Jan · Lomová Olga M Máca Roman · Mahdalová Eva · Máchalová Jana · Maláčová Jana · Málková Ivana · Marvanová Hana · Mašát Martin · Měska Jiří · Metelka Ladislav · Michálek Libor · Miller Robert · Minář Mikuláš · Minařík Petr · Mittner Jiří · Moore Markéta · Mrkvička Jan · Müller Zdeněk · Mundier Milan · Münich Daniel N Nacher Patrik · Nachtigallová Mariana Novotná · Návrat Petr · Navrátil Marek · Němec Václav · Nerudová Danuše · Nerušil Josef · Niedermayer Luděk · Nosková Věra · Nouzová Pavlína · Nováčková Jana · Novák Aleš · Novotný Martin · Novotný Vít · Nožička Josef O Obluk Karel · Ocelák Radek · Oláh Michal · Ouhel Tomáš · Oujezdská Marie · Outlý Jan P Pačes Václav · Palik Michal · Paroubek Jiří · Pavel Petr · Pavelka Zdenko · Payne Jan · Payne Petr Pazdera · Pehe Jiří · Peksa Mikuláš · Pelda Zdeněk · Petrák Milán · Petříček Tomáš · Petříčková Iva · Pfeffer Vladimír · Pfeiler Tomáš · Pícha Vladimír · Pilip Ivan · Pitek Daniel · Pixová Michaela · Plaček Jan · Podzimek Jan · Pohled zblízka · Polách Kamil · Polčák Stanislav · Potměšilová Hana · Pražskej blog · Prouza Tomáš R Rabas Přemysl · Rajmon David · Rakušan Vít · Ráž Roman · Redakce Aktuálně.cz  · Reiner Martin · Richterová Olga · Robejšek Petr · Ruščák Andrej · Rydzyk Pavel · Rychlík Jan Ř Řebíková Barbora · Řeháčková Karolína Avivi · Říha Miloš · Řízek Tomáš S Sedlák Martin · Seitlová Jitka · Schneider Ondřej · Schwarzenberg Karel · Sirový Michal · Skalíková Lucie · Skuhrovec Jiří · Sládek Jan · Sláma Bohumil · Slavíček Jan · Slejška Zdeněk · Slimáková Margit · Smoljak David · Smutný Pavel · Sobíšek Pavel · Sokačová Linda · Soukal Josef · Soukup Ondřej · Sportbar · Staněk Antonín · Stanoev Martin · Stehlík Michal · Stehlíková Džamila · Stránský Martin Jan · Strmiska Jan · Stulík David · Svárovský Martin · Svoboda Cyril · Svoboda Jiří · Svoboda Pavel · Sýkora Filip · Syrovátka Jonáš Š Šebek Tomáš · Šefrnová Tereza · Šimáček Martin · Šimková Karolína · Šindelář Pavel · Šípová Adéla · Šlechtová Karla · Šmíd Milan · Šojdrová Michaela · Šoltés Michal · Špalková Veronika Krátká · Špinka Filip · Špok Dalibor · Šteffl Ondřej · Štěpán Martin · Štěpánek Pavel · Štern Ivan · Štern Jan · Štětka Václav · Štrobl Daniel T T. Tereza · Táborský Adam · Tejkalová N. Alice · Telička Pavel · Titěrová Kristýna · Tolasz Radim · Tománek Jan · Tomčiak Boris · Tomek Prokop · Tomský Alexander · Trantina Pavel · Tůma Petr · Turek Jan U Uhl Petr · Urban Jan V Vacková Pavla · Václav Petr · Vaculík Jan · Vácha Marek · Valdrová Jana · Vančurová Martina · Vavruška Dalibor · Věchet Martin Geronimo · Vendlová Veronika · Vhrsti · Vích Tomáš · Vlach Robert · Vodrážka Mirek · Vojtěch Adam · Vojtková Michaela Trtíková · Vostrá Denisa · Výborný Marek · Vyskočil František W Walek Czeslaw · Wichterle Kamil · Wirthová Jitka · Witassek Libor Z Zádrapa Lukáš · Zajíček Zdeněk · Zaorálek Lubomír · Závodský Ondřej · Zelený Milan · Zeman Václav · Zima Tomáš · Zlatuška Jiří · Zouzalík Marek Ž Žák Miroslav · Žák Václav · Žantovský Michael · Žantovský Petr Ostatní Dlouhodobě neaktivní blogy