Grameen bank: A multinational corporation based on solidarity?

04. 04. 2010 | 16:16
Přečteno 252475 krát
In the 16th chapter of David Korten´s famous book „When corporations rule the world“, the author claims the following: „According to the conventional economic thinking the (global) marketplace disciplines firms to maintain economical efficiency. In the global economy however, the largest corporations have learned how to manage competition to minimize it for themselves while maximizing it for others – using it as one more management tool to pass more on their own costs onto peoples and communities“. Korten states that contrarily to the neoliberal argument that global markets create better competition and higher efficiency, the reality which is happening around the globalising world is exactly the opposite one. Quantifying the market dominance of several oligopolies of big multinational corporations including General Motors, Wal Mart or Kraft Foods, the american economist argues that these evergrowing international businesses are rather systematically damaging and destroying the small and middle-sized national and local firms. As the corporations go on merging and fusioning in order to increase their efficiency and profitability, they are occupying still larger part of their respective markets. This process gives less and less space to the small businesses and therefore reduces the competition and concurrence. As a consequence of the imperative of the limitless growth, these multinationals are continuously downsizing their staffs, and concentrating power which leads to the growing centralization of benefits, and unemployment and empoverishment of the whole communities around the world´s peripheries.


Transposing these ideas into the Czech environment, we could certainly find several domains where similar parallels can be found in the nowadays crisis. But it is not the point I would like to make today. One month ago, I took part in a conference about social business where I heard a speech of the bangladeshi professor of economics and Nobel prize for peace winner Muhammad Yunus. He was talking about his view of doing business – „social business“ in his words – based on an idea of helping the poorest people around the world to escape from the vicious circle of poverty by lending them small sums of money. These so called „microcredits“ gained a spectacular success all around the world and Yunuses Grameen Bank, launched in Bangladesh in 1983, rapidly expanded and continuously mushroomed in other countries. Nowadays, Grameen Bank operates in more than 40 countries including USA and in 2006 its net income was more than 20 million dollars. For some, fabulous success on both economic and especially social level. More than 97% of Grameen bank´s borrowers are women and the system of lending money is conditioned not only by repaying the debts (financial return) but also by behaving according to the „16 decissions“ - such as a contition of sending children to school, drinking clean water or maintaining sanitary precautions etc. Thanks to this „educative“ dimension, thousands of families manage to improve their living standards and some even escape the poverty (social return).

On the other hand, looking at Yunus through Korten´s lenses, we could also develop several critical arguments. Yunuses Grameen bank is, in a way, accepting the neoliberal approach as it continuously becomes a multinational corporation itself. By investing in the world´s poorest populations through yielding loans, these are becoming indebted and dependent on the power cumulated by Grameen bank. We could also argue that in its market, Grameen bank often holds a monopoly or at least occupies a large part of the market which would, according to Korten´s arguments, drive off the concurrence and reduce the competitivity. Last but not least, as Grameen bank accepts the growth imperative, it should be obliged by the market pressures to increase the economic performance and its gains. Comparing to the usual banks´ interest rates, Grameen´s interest rate on its main credit product in 2006 was close to 20% and some of its „moral conditions“ could be easily interpreted as an imposition of a the market ideology. Muhamad Yunus continues in expanding and multiplying his businesses and since a few years he has been cooperating with several large multinational corporations such as Danone or Veolia.

But still, there are some facts about Grameen Bank that are not fitting well in Korten´s description of multinational corporation´s impacts. The first one concerns its relation to unemployment. Grameen Bank doesn´t seem to „colonize“ markets in the same way as General Motors. On the contrary it creates new markets, attracts new investments and helps the poorest to create their own small businesses, to learn the meaning of responsibility and saving money and to support the self-employment. Neither does Grameen Bank merge with other companies in order to become more profitable. Again, we observe something rather opposite. More and more banks are introducing „microcredits“ and more and more entreprises are getting interested not in buying, but in cooperating with Grameen Bank. Remains the last point mentioned by Korten´s description of multinational corporation – the concentration of power and capital in the hands of minority getting richer. If the Grameen bank´s websites don´t lie, we find a surprising answer, this time totally contradictory: 94% of the bank´s equity is owned by the borrowers themselves. Grameen banks is almost purely a cooperative bank. Only the remaining 6% are said to belong to the Government of Bangladesh. Does that mean that the founder of Grameen bank Muhammad Yunus doesn´t own any single percent of his own business? Are we still talking about the multinational corporation in a Korten´s sense? And if the answer is „no“, what kind of multinational corporation are we then talking about? Is the term ever appropriate for this kind of „business“? And considering the potential impact of Grameen bank´s inspiration for thousands of businessmen all around the world, is it appropriate to think that this kind of market-based solutions can contribute to more just, equal and wealthy world in the „non-profit“ sense of this word?

P.S. Aby řeč nestála, připojuji něco ze školních škamen a vyzývám své anglicky mluvící přátele k diskusi :)

Blogeři abecedně

A Aktuálně.cz Blog · Atapana Mnislav Zelený B Baar Vladimír · Babka Michael · Balabán Miloš · Bartoníček Radek · Bartošek Jan · Bartošová Ela · Bavlšíková Adéla · Bečková Kateřina · Bednář Vojtěch · Bělobrádek Pavel · Beránek Jan · Berkovcová Jana · Bernard Josef · Berwid-Buquoy Jan · Bielinová Petra · Bína Jiří · Bízková Rut · Blaha Stanislav · Blažek Kamil · Bobek Miroslav · Boehmová Tereza · Brenna Yngvar · Bureš Radim · Bůžek Lukáš · Byčkov Semjon C Cerman Ivo · Cizinsky Ludvik Č Černoušek Štěpán · Česko Chytré · Čipera Erik · Čtenářův blog D David Jiří · Davis Magdalena · Dienstbier Jiří · Dlabajová Martina · Dolejš Jiří · Dostál Ondřej · Dudák Vladislav · Duka Dominik · Duong Nguyen Thi Thuy · Dvořák Jan · Dvořák Petr · Dvořáková Vladimíra E Elfmark František F Fafejtová Klára · Fajt Jiří · Fendrych Martin · Fiala Petr · Fibigerová Markéta · Fischer Pavel G Gálik Stanislav · Gargulák Karel · Geislerová Ester · Girsa Václav · Glanc Tomáš · Goláň Tomáš · Gregorová Markéta · Groman Martin H Hájek Jan · Hála Martin · Halík Tomáš · Hamáček Jan · Hampl Václav · Hamplová Jana · Hapala Jiří · Hasenkopf Pavel · Hastík František · Havel Petr · Heller Šimon · Herman Daniel · Heroldová Martina · Hilšer Marek · Hladík Petr · Hlaváček Petr · Hlubučková Andrea · Hnízdil Jan · Hokovský Radko · Holásková Kamila · Holmerová Iva · Honzák Radkin · Horáková Adéla · Horký Petr · Hořejš Nikola · Hořejší Václav · Hrabálek Alexandr · Hradilková Jana · Hrstka Filip · Hřib Zdeněk · Hubálková Pavla · Hubinger Václav · Hülle Tomáš · Hušek Radek · Hvížďala Karel CH Charanzová Dita · Chlup Radek · Chromý Heřman · Chýla Jiří · Chytil Ondřej J Janda Jakub · Janeček Karel · Janeček Vít · Janečková Tereza · Janyška Petr · Jelínková Michaela Mlíčková · Jourová Věra · Just Jiří · Just Vladimír K Kaláb Tomáš · Kania Ondřej · Karfík Filip · Karlický Josef · Klan Petr · Klepárník  Vít · Klíma Pavel · Klíma Vít · Klimeš David · Klusoň Jan · Kňapová Kateřina · Kocián Antonín · Kohoutová Růžena · Koch Paul Vincent · Kolaja Marcel · Kolářová Marie · Kolínská Petra · Kolovratník Martin · Konrádová Kateřina · Kopeček Lubomír · Kostlán František · Kotišová Miluš · Koudelka Zdeněk · Koutská Petra Schwarz · Kozák Kryštof · Krafl Martin · Krása Václav · Kraus Ivan · Kroupová Johana · Křeček Stanislav · Kubr Milan · Kučera Josef · Kučera Vladimír · Kučerová Karolína · Kuchař Jakub · Kuchař Jaroslav · Kukal Petr · Kupka Martin · Kuras Benjamin · Kutílek Petr · Kužílek Oldřich · Kyselý Ondřej L Laně Tomáš · Linhart Zbyněk · Lipavský Jan · Lipold Jan · Lomová Olga M Máca Roman · Mahdalová Eva · Máchalová Jana · Maláčová Jana · Málková Ivana · Marvanová Hana · Mašát Martin · Měska Jiří · Metelka Ladislav · Michálek Libor · Miller Robert · Minář Mikuláš · Minařík Petr · Mittner Jiří · Moore Markéta · Mrkvička Jan · Müller Zdeněk · Mundier Milan · Münich Daniel N Nacher Patrik · Nachtigallová Mariana Novotná · Návrat Petr · Navrátil Marek · Němec Václav · Nerudová Danuše · Nerušil Josef · Niedermayer Luděk · Nosková Věra · Nouzová Pavlína · Nováčková Jana · Novák Aleš · Novotný Martin · Novotný Vít · Nožička Josef O Obluk Karel · Ocelák Radek · Oláh Michal · Ouhel Tomáš · Oujezdská Marie · Outlý Jan P Pačes Václav · Palik Michal · Paroubek Jiří · Pavel Petr · Pavelka Zdenko · Payne Jan · Payne Petr Pazdera · Pehe Jiří · Peksa Mikuláš · Pelda Zdeněk · Petrák Milán · Petříček Tomáš · Petříčková Iva · Pfeffer Vladimír · Pfeiler Tomáš · Pícha Vladimír · Pilip Ivan · Pitek Daniel · Pixová Michaela · Plaček Jan · Podzimek Jan · Pohled zblízka · Polách Kamil · Polčák Stanislav · Potměšilová Hana · Pražskej blog · Prouza Tomáš R Rabas Přemysl · Rajmon David · Rakušan Vít · Ráž Roman · Redakce Aktuálně.cz  · Reiner Martin · Richterová Olga · Robejšek Petr · Ruščák Andrej · Rydzyk Pavel · Rychlík Jan Ř Řebíková Barbora · Řeháčková Karolína Avivi · Říha Miloš · Řízek Tomáš S Sedlák Martin · Seitlová Jitka · Schneider Ondřej · Schwarzenberg Karel · Sirový Michal · Skalíková Lucie · Skuhrovec Jiří · Sládek Jan · Sláma Bohumil · Slavíček Jan · Slejška Zdeněk · Slimáková Margit · Smoljak David · Smutný Pavel · Sobíšek Pavel · Sokačová Linda · Soukal Josef · Soukup Ondřej · Sportbar · Staněk Antonín · Stanoev Martin · Stehlík Michal · Stehlíková Džamila · Stránský Martin Jan · Strmiska Jan · Stulík David · Svárovský Martin · Svoboda Cyril · Svoboda Jiří · Svoboda Pavel · Sýkora Filip · Syrovátka Jonáš Š Šebek Tomáš · Šefrnová Tereza · Šimáček Martin · Šimková Karolína · Šindelář Pavel · Šípová Adéla · Šlechtová Karla · Šmíd Milan · Šojdrová Michaela · Šoltés Michal · Špalková Veronika Krátká · Špinka Filip · Špok Dalibor · Šteffl Ondřej · Štěpán Martin · Štěpánek Pavel · Štern Ivan · Štern Jan · Štětka Václav · Štrobl Daniel T T. Tereza · Táborský Adam · Tejkalová N. Alice · Telička Pavel · Titěrová Kristýna · Tolasz Radim · Tománek Jan · Tomčiak Boris · Tomek Prokop · Tomský Alexander · Trantina Pavel · Tůma Petr · Turek Jan U Uhl Petr · Urban Jan V Vacková Pavla · Václav Petr · Vaculík Jan · Vácha Marek · Valdrová Jana · Vančurová Martina · Vavruška Dalibor · Věchet Martin Geronimo · Vendlová Veronika · Vhrsti · Vích Tomáš · Vlach Robert · Vodrážka Mirek · Vojtěch Adam · Vojtková Michaela Trtíková · Vostrá Denisa · Výborný Marek · Vyskočil František W Walek Czeslaw · Wichterle Kamil · Wirthová Jitka · Witassek Libor Z Zádrapa Lukáš · Zajíček Zdeněk · Zaorálek Lubomír · Závodský Ondřej · Zelený Milan · Zeman Václav · Zima Tomáš · Zlatuška Jiří · Zouzalík Marek Ž Žák Miroslav · Žák Václav · Žantovský Michael · Žantovský Petr Ostatní Dlouhodobě neaktivní blogy